This action was taken under an unannounced rule that can label and censor criticism of anyone or anything with āFUD.ā
Youāll find itās only used to protect the rich and powerful, though.
Unable to simply delete the post, the moderators scrubbed comments from anyone who named and shamed CEO James Dolan, but allowed his supporters to remain uncensored.
Criticism of basically anyone rich or powerful was removed.
Criticism of Tucker Carlson was removed.
But yeah, fuck the r/privacy mods. I heard from another comment they moderate fosstodon too, is that true?
Yep, Carrotcypher is in the mod list.
https://hub.fosstodon.org/team/
I presume the admins just donāt know about this. They also moderate over 50 subreddits, including the Mastodon one. They tend to be the controlling moderator, or the top moderator that is regularly active.
Doing my best to compile more content about itā¦
It might be worth letting them know.
I am extremely convinced that bad actors have become pretty good at taking over subreddits, and I know there are companies that will sell services where they will do this sort of stuff (āreputation managementā) if you want the internet as a whole to have a better impression of your company, or overall control the narrative. I donāt really know anything at all about carrotcypher specifically, but it sounds a lot like this person might be doing something at least similar to that. So assembling something thatās well-documented and organized enough that itās hard to dismiss and then sharing it with any people who are giving carrotcypher a position of authority, sounds like a really good idea. I can help with it in any way if you want me to (although like I say I have no idea about this person specifically beyond suspicious things like this that people have brought up).
The fediverse is very vulnerable to this kind of stuff I think, just like Reddit is, because thereās always such a shortage of people who are really willing to put in the time and effort it takes to do behind-the-scenes work like moderation. I think we should definitely be vigilant about calling it out if it seems like someone is doing stuff thatās sketchy.
Now, or after a couple more posts? I have commented about this moderatorās political attitudes elsewhere but I still have a bit of a backlog of posts to release info about.
I feel like maybe with a blog post or something. Or just a post with a detailed laundry list of all the least defensible decisions. I think just having particular political attitudes are (in most cases) fineā¦ but the stuff like this that I have observed on Lemmy, and most of the stuff youāve been talking about, thereās simply no reasonable reason for. I feel like Reddit is sufficiently anonymous-because-of-bigness and sufficiently corrupted that they get sloppier with it over there.
I want to say it would be a good idea to reach out to carrotcypher and get their take on some of this stuff, too. Itās proper due diligence even though something about it makes me not like the idea.
https://lemm.ee/post/59705025/19248615
They seem to keep delivering
Oh yeah, thereās more where this came from. Iāve got a little backlog of content
Keep it coming, Iām glad to get this kind of info both about Dolan and meritless censorship on Reddit.
I think Reddit has strong anti witch hunt rules after the whole Boston bomber fiasco. Canāt fault them for going for āblast it from the orbitā approach, they couldnāt even keep Reddit profitable without resorting to hosting porn and you want them to have nuance in moderation.
They also ban criticism of the US government, US billionaires, and Israeli spywareā¦ I sure can fault them for doing this
I meant they canāt differentiate between them because thereās too many reports to go through probably. Reddit relies on volunteers because it canāt afford to employ enough people to moderate it for real.
If the moderators arenāt capable of handling this amount of work, they should divest themselves from the communities they volunteered for. Especially if their leisure time on Reddit is spent losing arguments to other people on subreddits they run.
Yes, thatās what I did. Some people delude themselves for various reasons into continuing though.
Is this sarcasm?
Reality can be funny and sad at the same time.
I can see modding Lemmy and mastodon for free bc they canāt afford it. Spez should make avocado toast and coffee at home to pay mods.